
There’s a special kind of year-end headache reserved for crypto fund managers. You can nail the trade, time the hedge perfectly, and still wind up explaining to investors why the tax bill looks nothing like the returns they were celebrating.
Blame the tax rules for cryptocurrency, which still begin with a 2014 IRS notice calling bitcoin property. Every crypto swap can trigger a taxable gain, certain futures get preferential treatment, and carried interest comes with its own three-year clock. December loss harvesting also used to offer some breathing room, until Congress decided to revisit that little perk in September. And now there’s legislation threatening to reach backward, just to keep things interesting.
At Michael Coglianese, CPA, P.C., we audit these funds and prepare their returns. We’ll walk through the five rules, including the new 1099-DA reporting headaches, and explain which moves we’d make before December 31 and which we’d leave alone.
The IRS treats crypto as property, which puts a bitcoin closer to a vacant lot than a dollar bill. Try explaining that to a trader swapping ether for solana in three seconds.
Say your fund bought $3 million of ether and later traded it for $5 million of solana. That’s a $2 million taxable gain, even though no cash changed hands. Your LPs may owe tax on their share, and a K-1 arriving months later is a rotten way to deliver the news.
The real estate comparison gets worse. Property investors can defer certain gains under Section 1031, but crypto lost that option in 2018. Even paying a network fee in tokens can create another taxable disposition.
Multiply that by a year of rebalancing, and your trading history starts looking like a tax preparer’s ransom note. Keep the cost basis current, and give your LPs fair warning before December.
There is one upside to the IRS treating bitcoin like a vacant lot. The wash-sale rule stops stock investors from selling at a loss and immediately buying back in, but Section 1091 generally leaves crypto alone. Your fund can sell bitcoin at a loss before lunch, buy it back afterward, and still claim the deduction.
Congress, however, thinks lunch should last longer.
H.R. 10357 cleared House Ways and Means 38-5 in September and would extend wash-sale restrictions to most crypto, potentially reaching back to trades made after September 14. It hasn’t become law, but we’d hate to see your December tax strategy depend on congressional gridlock.
Our advice? Treat the 30-day window on either side of a loss sale as already binding, and watch wrapped-token exposure too. Sitting out a month beats explaining to your LPs why their seven-figure deduction disappeared.
After that wash-sale warning, your trading desk deserves some good news. Congress wrote a pretty generous tax deal for commodity futures back in 1981, and qualifying bitcoin and ether futures on the CME get to enjoy it.
Under Section 1256, 60% of your gains get long-term capital gains treatment, and 40% get short-term treatment, even if you held the contract for 20 minutes. On $1 million in profits, that’s roughly $268,000 in federal income tax for a top-bracket individual partner, compared with $370,000 on a short-term spot trade, before other taxes.
Naturally, the IRS wants something in return. Every open contract gets taxed at year-end as though you’d sold it, whether you’ve cashed out or not.
Offshore perpetual futures generally miss out on this deal. Your traders may see the same bitcoin exposure, but your LPs will see a very different tax bill.
That CME tax break is nice. Now for the part of the return that hits you, the fund manager, personally: your carry.
Your LPs generally qualify for long-term capital gains rates after holding an asset for more than a year. Under Section 1061, managers collecting carried interest generally need the fund to hold it for more than three. Congress had private equity in mind, where three years is practically a coffee break. Three years in crypto is enough time for the top ten coins to become a history lesson.
Remember our $2 million ether gain from Rule 1? If the fund held it for two years, your LPs get long-term treatment. Your 20% carry, worth $400,000, gets taxed at short-term rates. That’s $148,000 versus $80,000 at the top federal rates, before other taxes. Ouch.
One consolation, though: qualifying Section 1256 futures gains escape the three-year carry rule.
After four rules about what you owe, the fifth concerns what the IRS already knows. And thanks to Form 1099-DA, it’s getting a much better look at your trading history.
U.S. exchanges and custodians now report crypto sales directly to the IRS. The amusing part is that they can tell the government exactly what you sold it for without necessarily knowing what you paid. Mandatory basis reporting generally starts with coins acquired in 2026 and held on the same platform. Older holdings and wallet transfers can leave some rather expensive blanks.
Let’s go back to Rule 1 again with our $5 million ether swap. The IRS may see $5 million in proceeds, while the $3 million cost basis sits in your records. Guess who gets to explain the difference?
Keep your basis wallet by wallet, reconcile the forms against your books, and settle discrepancies before your LPs receive their K-1s.
Look back at the five rules and nearly all of them come down to things you can only fix before the year closes. You can’t harvest a loss in January, you can’t add a year to a holding period after you’ve sold, and nobody wants to rebuild two years of wallet records the week K-1s are due.
That’s why we’d rather hear from you now. Michael Coglianese, CPA, P.C. has worked with alternative investment funds for more than 35 years, and Michael started his career auditing firms inside the NFA’s Compliance Department. Our tax and audit teams sit under one roof, so the people preparing your K-1s know what your auditor will ask about the same wallets.
You also get a partner who picks up the phone, at a fee sized to a fund like yours. If your fund will be holding crypto on December 31, talk to an expert while the year is still open. Tell us what you hold and how you traded, and we’ll tell you which calls you can still make.
No. As of November 13, 2026, H.R. 10357 has cleared the House Ways and Means Committee but hasn’t passed either chamber, and it expires unless enacted before the new Congress is seated on January 3, 2027. If it passes as written, its wash-sale rule reaches sales after September 14, 2026.
Yes. Rev. Rul. 2023-14, which addresses cash-method taxpayers, treats staking rewards as ordinary income at fair market value once you can sell or transfer them. The Tax Court reached the same result in Paschall v. Commissioner in June 2026. The amount you report becomes your cost basis in those tokens.
Yes, for now. Through December 31, 2026, Notice 2026-20 lets you identify the specific lots you sold in your own books. Starting in 2027, coins held at a broker need that instruction on file with the broker before the trade. Without one, the sale defaults to first in, first out.
Only if what it trades counts as securities or commodities, and it’s unsettled whether spot tokens are commodities under Section 475. H.R. 10357 would add a separate election for crypto traders. A calendar-year fund generally has to elect by March 15, 2027, for the 2027 tax year, as our Section 475(f) guide explains.
Not with confidence yet. Section 864(b)(2) lets foreign investors trade stocks, securities, and exchange-traded commodities through a U.S. manager without being treated as doing business here. No IRS guidance says spot tokens qualify, though H.R. 10357 would add them. Until then, get a written opinion before your offshore investors rely on it.



We’re here to serve you as your partner. To get started, fill out this form, and we’ll be in touch with you soon.
Lincolnshire Office
Michael Coglianese
CPA, P.C. ​
300 Tri State
International
Suite 180
Lincolnshire, Il. 60069
​
630.351.4005
info@cogcpa.com